Recently I read a blog post by Pete Wilson on social media and an article he had read posing the idea that Facebook is killing us from within. He posted a chunk of the article here. The author was posing the thought that while social media is giving us the ability to connect with anyone and everyone, it is also turning us into narcissists.
As someone that uses social media on several platforms, I’d love to say yes and no, but that’s not fun so I am just gonna disagree and speak from my experience. I’m not going to sit here and try to convince you that there are no self-centered actions on the Internet, but I won’t agree that in general that is the case. Seems to me that there are 4 types of social media users.
- Spectator/Casual – Here you have your beginners, dabblers, toe dippers, repeaters (start using it, then quickly die out, then repeat) and onlookers. They have heard that everyone is on a social media, but they aren’t really sure it’s for them.
- Business/Spam – Click here for flatter stomachs, bigger muscles, cheaper prices, etc. All we do here is push our business or blog. There is nothing personal or relational about our social media usage.
- Celebrity/Mr. Universe – We like to hear ourselves talk. We like to look in the mirror and see ourselves. I think therefore you listen. Right?
- Frequent/Community – These people have taken the plunge and are finding out the potential of social media. They are sharing their thoughts, feelings and pictures as well as receiving the same from the rest of their chosen community.
3 of these groups are missing the point. Casual users see what appears to be a world-revolves-around-me narcissistic mess. Spammer help the casual users come to their conclusion. The celebrity is, well…obvious. Community is where the meat is, though. On the outside the casual user looks at the frequent users and sees lots of tweets or status updates about their lives and what they like or don’t like and where they are. But they aren’t seeing the rest of the community that cares about that stuff.
When you go hang out with your friends over dinner, do you share stories and pictures and thoughts with them or do you just sit around in silence with brief small talk? Of course! You share with them! They are your friends! They care about you and your life and you care about them and theirs. That’s how social media works as well. It’s just a bit more public!
I personally am in a community of people that uses social media to its fullest. Sometimes it is too much for me but that’s no different than any other physical community of friends. I love them. I wanna know what is going on with them, what they are thinking and feeling, and the funny sign they just saw. That’s what friends do. I know that online community can be just as loving, caring and supportive as physical community. In fact I had a friend tell me before that they felt better community and love from their online friends than they did from their church and physical community. It would probably be tough for someone to convince my friend that it’s mainly narcissism and a waste of time.
So, what say you? Do you feel differently? Are you willing to lump all social media into the self-centered look at me crowd or do you see redemption and value in it?